Thursday, 09 April 2015 17:52

Which social sharing icons should we be using? AddThis? ShareThis? Shareaholic?

Written by 

First, a bit of clarification because my clients frequently ask this question: what’s the difference between "social icons" and "social sharing icons”?  Social icons are links to your company’s social pages, like Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIN.  On these pages, people can directly engage with your organization by posting photos, asking questions, and the like.  

Social SHARING icons are visually similar as well, they will typically include Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIN, Google+, Pinterest… these are used for sharing content from your company’s website on your site visitors’ social media accounts (newsfeeds, or pages).  When your site’s visitors share your content throughout their social circles, it translates into free exposure for your content.  Assuming that you are producing relevant, high-quality content, this should translate into increased revenues, profits, and market share for your organization.

Now that mobile devices are becoming more and more important, the social icons that we built into sites a few years ago will not be ideal.  For one, they may include social sharing links to sites that are no longer relevant (MySpace anyone?).  Older social sharing icons are typically not responsive, meaning they are easy to click on using a mouse, but are too small for a finger to click using a smart phone.  



ShareThis is a free service.  It seems that current versions of their buttons are responsive, so if you are already using ShareThis but the buttons are not responsive, contact us and we’ll help in swapping out the code for a responsive variety.




AddThis is also a free service, but in order to get their responsive buttons, you need a PRO account starting at $10/month.  



Like ShareThis and AddThis, Shareaholic is a free service.  I have chosen the Shareaholic sharing buttons for this site for several reasons.  For one, their free service includes responsive buttons, which is great.  Shareaholic also has a cute “Sharing is caring!” headline above the buttons, which seems to subtly nudge visitors towards sharing your site’s content.  Of course, we could add this type of headline above the ShareThis or AddThis buttons, but let’s not get carried away.  Another nice thing about the Sharaholic service is they offer the ability to (optionally) display ads on your site after someone shares an article, which is a potential revenue stream for your site.  


I wouldn’t get too carried away with deciding which social sharing button service is best.  If you’re already using one of these, there’s likely not much reason to switch, if you’re happy with how it works.  Each service includes its own set of Analytics (reporting system) so that you can see which social platforms perform best for your site’s content.  You can also integrate ShareThis and AddThis with Google Analytics.  It seems the Sharaholics service does not integrate its Analytics platform with Google, if that makes a difference.

Read 8279 times Last modified on Thursday, 09 April 2015 18:00
0 #1 Pamela Hazelton 2015-05-04 02:57
Unfortunately, Shareaholic has, for some time now, turned on many settings by default. Settings that "hijack" outgoing links and display questionable content in related sections which are designed to monetize your sight. However, many users are unaware those settings are on.

I covered this in great detail last September. They've made a few changes since, but not much.
Add comment